|Name||Eli Peter Madison|
|Family|| Diane Wharsey (first ex-wife)|
Caroline Madison (second ex-wife; status unknown)
|First Appearance||"Hands Free"|
Eli Peter Madison is a homosexual, cross-dressing millionaire who was the prime suspect of the disappearance of his second ex-wife Caroline, and the murder and dismemberment of his neighbor Roger Barry.
There was no evidence to implicate him in Caroline's disappearance, while he was acquitted for second-degree murder in relation to the death of Barry. However, a follow-up investigation found Madison responsible for the New Mexico death of his friend and lover Dwayne Evans, who would have corroborated an alibi he had for Caroline's disappearance.
- 1994, New York City, New York: Caroline Madison (his wife; disappeared; was never found)
- 1996, New Mexico: Dwayne Evans (murdered and covered up his death as a rock-climbing accident)