Robert Morten was a serial killer who tortured and killed eight young women in the belief that he could turn killing into an art form. When he was caught, he didn't even bother to deny his actions, instead relishing the infamy that his trial brought him. He was given eight life sentences for his crimes, but much to the horror of his prosecutors, he attracted a small cult following, which grew after artist Harrison Thomas wrote and drew the Le Morte comic book series, which not only recounted Morten's crimes, but tried to predict what kind of murders he'd do if he'd remained uncaptured.
Years passed, with Morten heavily confined but content with the waves of mail sent in by loving fans. And then, one day, Morten was contacted by young Cecelia Strayer, the daughter of a former cellmate. Cecelia had recently learned that her father had not died in a car crash when she was young, as she'd long believed, but had, in fact, been arrested and jailed for a string of bank robberies. Cecelia desperately wanted to know more about her father, and Morten promised to tell her everything. He convinced her to get an internship the law firm that had defended him, so that she could have unmonitored visits with him in prison. Once she was inside, he seduced her and they ended up making love on at least one occasion.
Cecelia fell head over heels for Morten, but he soon grew bored of her and dumped her, saying that she was incapable of understanding his real needs, his desire to see more blood and spatter. Cecelia thought she could win his heart if she could reproduce his work. To this end, she drugged Tina Snow, an acquaintance of hers, and then bound, mutilated, and killed the girl. But she discovered that she did not enjoy the killing, and grew suicidal from guilt. After learning that the Special Victims Unit was investigating the case, and knowing that her actions would only make life worse for Morten, Cecelia broke into Morten's childhood home and attempted suicide by downing a bottle of Vodka with GHB and slashing herself across the chest repeatedly. By sheer luck, she was found by the SVU before dying from blood loss. Shortly after, the police discovered her connection to Morton and she was put on trial for Tina Snow's murder.
Morten agreed to testify against Cecelia in exchange for the possibility of parole and a transfer to a federal prison. In court, he testified that not only had he never instructed Cecelia to kill for her, but he also had not belief in her abilities as an artist. Cecelia got upset and tried to run over to him, causing her to be removed from the courtroom, thus earning her an acquittal and a stay in a psych ward. Morten left the courthouse feeling jubilant, only to discover that Novak had arranged for him to be transferred to a super-maximum-security federal prison so that he would never have any more human contact.