|Affiliation||My Salvation Charities|
|Pathology|| Double murderer|
Serial statutory rapist
Ted Carthage was a philanthropist and the prime suspect in the rape and murder of Monica Phelps and the murder of her longtime friend Gina Arroyo.
Before killing Monica and Gina, Carthage was also a suspect in a small number of rapes, and had paid his victims to have sex with him.
After he was arrested before he could have sex with a repeat underage customer, Nathan Phelps, son of Monica, accidentally identified another suspect in his mother's murder in the police lineup.
- Committed several unspecified statutory rapes
- Katie (raped)
- Gina Arroyo (shot twice in the chest)
- Monica Phelps (raped and shot twice in the chest)